The Hollars (Sony Pictures Classics) isn't the first movie to deal with a dying parent or an adult child who returns to a small town from the big city to the deal with the situation. It is, however, the first to have the magnificent Margo Martindale in the role of the terminally ill parent, and that alone sets it apart from all others.
Director and star John Krasinski had his work cut out for him, turning the sow's ear of Jim Strouse's screenplay into a silk purse, and he does an admirable job. Hollar matriarch Sally (Martindale) lives with her husband Don (the ubiquitous Richard Jenkins) and incompetent son Ron (a miserably miscast Sharlto Copley) in Ohio. Artistic son John (Krasinski) lives in New York with his pregnant girlfriend Rebecca (Anna Kendrick), where he works at a publishing company and struggles with what to do with his graphic novel.
When Sally passes out in the bathroom while using a curling iron on her hair, leading to a burn on her wrist, she is taken to the hospital where it is discovered that she has a sizable brain tumor that has been growing for several years. Both Sally and Don ignored the symptoms (Don sent Sally to Jenny Craig thinking they were weight-related) and now Sally has to undergo a craniotomy.
John returns to Ohio to be with his family, leaving Rebecca behind in New York. Of course that won't do and the independently wealthy Rebecca hails a cab to Ohio to be with John. It's a good thing she's there, too, because John's married ex-girlfriend Gwen (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) still has the hots for him.
In the days leading up to Sally's procedure, secrets are revealed, truths are told and arrests are made. Ron, concerned about his young daughters and obsessed with ex-wife Stacy's (Ashley Dyke) relationship with Reverend Dave (Josh Groban) acts even more inappropriately than he is known for doing. Sally confides in John about her relationship with Don and her discarded dreams. John and Rebecca must face the fact that they are soon going to be parents (of twins!).
The Hollars is a cookie-cutter affair redeemed by Martindale's Oscar-worthy performance. There are some scenes that stand out as highly original, including the one in which John shaves Sally's head with clippers in advance of her surgery. But don't be surprised if you find yourself hollering at the screen that you've seen some of this before. [In theaters on Sept. 16]