For an author as beloved and respected as Philip Roth, film adaptations of his work, particularly the ones made during the 21st century, have not fared all that well. The most well-received one of all Roth adaptations, the Oscar-nominated Goodbye, Columbus (from 1969), has become such a part of popular culture that references to over-indulgent sweet tables at catered affairs earn the movie a name-checking. The 1972 film version of Portnoy's Complaint, from Roth's most notorious novel, didn't do well with critics or audiences. The PBS American Playhouse adaptation of The Ghost Writer was a big hit in 1984, but almost 20 years passed before there was a renewed cinematic interest in Roth's work, resulting in the films The Human Stain (starring out actor Wentworth Miller, Nicole Kidman and Anthony Hopkins), Elegy (starring Penelope Cruz and Ben Kingsley) and The Humbling (starring Al Pacino and Greta Gerwig). All three were mostly forgettable.
James Schamus' film rendition of Indignation (RT Features), his feature-length directorial debut, has the potential to change all of that. Framed by scenes of an elderly woman in a nursing home looking at a wallpaper pattern and a Korean war flashback, the film takes us back to 1951 where New Jersey native Marcus (Logan Lerman in a fine performance) is preparing to leave his friends and family behind and begin his freshman year of college at Winesburg College in Ohio (where the mother of one of his friends wonders where he'll find Kosher food). Marcus' departure, at a time when young men are dying with regularity in the Korean war, creates an almost insurmountable situation with his parents, with him being the only son of worrisome butcher Max (Danny Burstein) and homemaker Esther (Linda Edmond who deserves a Best Supporting Actress nod come Oscar time).