A popular professor, Arendt was beloved by her students as well as her co-workers, including the writer Mary McCarthy (Janet McTeer). She lived with her husband Heinrich (Axel Milberg), with whom she enjoyed entertaining friends in their home. But the news of Eichmann's arrest had a strange effect on Arendt. Having briefly spent time in the French detention camp Gurs, as a German Jew, Arendt had never seen a Nazi in the flesh. Due to her name and reputation in academia in the United States, her request to cover the trial, in Jerusalem, for The New Yorker is given the green light, even though "philosophers don't make deadlines."
In spite of appearances, von Trotta has not made a traditional biopic. The flashbacks, which include Arendt's affair with her mentor (and later member of the Nazi party) Martin Heidegger (Klaus Pohl), are kept to a minimum. The trial scenes include the actual black & white vintage footage of the Eichmann trial, which can be jarring at first.
Where Hannah Arendt make its greatest impact is in the conflict that arises after Hannah returns to the States and writes her controversial New Yorker article. Coming at the subject not as a historian, a journalist or even a Jew, Arendt's cold, clinical philosophical approach doesn't sit well with many readers. She is barraged by hate mail. Close friends including Kurt (Michael Degen) and Hans (Ulrich Noethen) turn against her. Even those who once supported her in her department at school jump on the bandwagon.
Hannah Arendt is a multi-tiered story of survival. Offering no easy answers, but giving viewers a lot to think about, the film is a little too long. But Sukowa's performance is riveting and as history lessons go, it's one where you will feel as if you learned something you didn't know before. (Opens Aug. 16 at Landmark Century Theater.)