Turtle Hill, Brooklyn (Believe Ltd.) Co-written by and co-starring Brian W. Siebert and Ricardo Valdez, the queer rom-com-drama Turtle Hill, Brooklyn (Believe Ltd.) is the kind of movie that can restore one's faith in low-budget indie gay films. Its effect is the complete opposite of, say Scrooge & Marley. It is proof that a film can be created on a shoestring budget without looking frayed or knotted.
Young gay couple Will (Seibert) and Mateo (Valdez) cohabitate in the Turtle Hill neighborhood of Brooklyn. Will wakes up the morning of his 30th birthday to find Mateo holding a cupcake with a single lit candle. A birthday party is planned for the day ahead in which numerous guests will be present to celebrate in the couple's colorfully decorate backyard. What would a party, involving the intake of various substances, both legal and not, be without conflict? Fortunately, Turtle Hill, Brooklyn has plenty to spare.
The first high drama moment occurs when Will's homophobic sister Molly (Jeanne Slater), stops by unexpectedly with her husband and young daughter. Surprised to find a shirtless and kilted Mateo at Will's (he's not out to his family) she launches into a toxic tirade and is asked to leave. The next bearer of bad news is Luis (Ariel Bonilla), who announces that he's moving to Spain with his boyfriend. A lying theme also emerges, as various friends talk about the virtues of dishonesty. There are also topical discussions involving politics (one deluded guest is a proud Log Cabin Republican), gay marriage and other hot button issues.
Turtle Hill, Brooklyn also has its share of humorous moments. The piñata pummeling is quite funny, as is the leak in the kiddy pool. But it's ultimately the conflict, including the return of Molly or the revelation of Mateo's affair with personal trainer Mauricio (Josh Marcantel), which gives the movie its energy, more than filling the bill. Like The Boys in the Band, another classic gay film set at a birthday party, Turtle Hill, Brooklyn makes good use of the multi-character storyline without ever losing focus of the main characters' needs and motivations. Because of that, it's worth scoring and invitation to this party and paying a visit to Turtle Hill, Brooklyn. The DVD includes feature commentary by Seibert and Valdez, as well as director Ryan Gielen and cast members, and more.